Discussion in 'Critique Forum Archives' started by Tuna, Nov 27, 2004.
All comments and critique greatly appreciated.
beautiful image, but not a realistic. If you were editing for the sureal, then you've achieved your goal. I like it.
another windows wallpaper! i like the saturation a lot. is this simply adding the sat in PS?
I love the work.
Analog or Digital? Details pls.
Digital (D70, 12-24mm). Composite image with some heavy-handed levels, curves, dodging/burning, etc. Partial result of another project I was working on...
Nice shot, but surely doesn't seem realistic. Good editing, though!
The image above was done to match the needs of the project but I have an earlier version of the image that may satisfy the "realist" view of what it should look like...
It looks a bit simple to me, but also a bit more realistic. Still too saturated, though.
If it were mine, I'd definitely keep it.
I like the image overall, though. I guess I forgot to mention that.
Cool shot! I like the original much more than the burnt/dodged one. The first is taking away the simple-ness which is what makes the seconds comp so unique. The first was done for a project? are there other variations of this shot?
Those are my thoughts, coming from mygrain! :sillysmi:
Separate names with a comma.