Discussion in 'Critique Forum Archives' started by pursuer, Mar 26, 2005.
The first one just looks too fake, but I love the tones in the second. Good job =)
nope... I like the idea of the first one... for me it is very deep and moving.. you know ... window on world... ehh I'm reading too much of Dan Brown's
Thanks for the feeback. I think you are both right. I prefer the color version but I think it was a bit over saturated so I tried toning it down a bit.
I think I actually like the oversaturation in the first. It seems to represent a fantasy world and then inside teh building is the complete opposite of that. I like the emotion the image conveys. Great idea, IMO the first is much better
I prefer the full B&W one - nice job.
I like the desaturated color one.
I like the first over saturated image.
I like the first one, love the mixed tones.
A lot of of different opinions here, thanks for the input everyone, much apprieciated.
i liked the first one best myself. i would like to see it with the interior in a very dark sepia tone, it might make the outside look less saturated without having to lose the vibrant colour
Separate names with a comma.