color, black and white, or strange sepia

thebeginning · May 15, 2005

not sure which of these i like best...thought i'd get some outside influence

please feel free to critique the photo as well!

ShutteredEye · May 15, 2005

LOL, I like the composition of the bottom one, but I think I'd like it in color. So, D, none of the above! :lol:

Digital Matt · May 15, 2005

I prefer #2, in terms of both composition, and also choice of B&W. I do however think that some more contrast, and possibly some dodging of the shack to bring out its' texture would help give it the "punch" it's lacking. Maybe a slight crop at the top to eliminate some of that white sky.

Meysha · May 15, 2005

I like the comp of #2 the best. I think the flowers cover up too much of the barn in #1.
And I like the colour effect in the third one.
Each of them is alright on its own - but can you combine them all together?

dalebe · May 15, 2005

I like the composition and tone of #3

JonMikal · May 15, 2005

#2 :thumbup:

Allsmiles7282 · May 15, 2005

JonMikal's avatar makes me dizzy...i'm feeling sleeeepppy....

j/k

I like the color one the best. I like the red with the yellow flowers.

Johnboy2978 · May 16, 2005

Generally, I'd rather see B&W, though I think in this example #1 does it for me. I like the yellow of the flowers in #1. I like the B&W too, but I'd crop a little of the sky out.