Not quite as exciting as a Quantum weather butterfly (points if you know where this is from), but a comment by a member here caused me to dig out an old shot (ok not that old but old by my count). Below you can see the shot itself as it is in its original out of camera composition and below that you can see the crop I made at the time. http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2730/4314077575_6262ff4bf0_o.jpg http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3098/3230189724_fa1a66465a_o.jpg So now you have seen the image the question arises was the crop correct? It's a simple question so lets see what answers we get. And because the hope is that disscusion can arise lets have answers with a bit of explination as well (rather than just one or two words ).