dangerwoman
TPF Noob!
- Joined
- Apr 17, 2005
- Messages
- 129
- Reaction score
- 0
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
Maybe I dont understand what makes a quality picture. But the first one is awesome.
That second one would be awesome with some minor touchups and PP. I would at the very least use the curves tool and brighten it a bit.
i think technical stuff is definitly benificial BUT if you look at a photo and it looks good, then thats good enough for me
No, the important thing is if the viewer knows why it looks good. A 'wowie' from a person who's unused to judging photographs is essentially meaningless to the photographer. It may mean that it is really a good photo, it may mean that the viewer just loves the content - irrespective of the picture. (like grandchildren photos)
IMO, these pictures (#1,2) would be better if the limbs hadn't been amputated.
i dont think that a person has to be well versed in the area of photography to look at a photograph and like it. the viewer doesnt need to know Why it looks good. i dont make photographs for other photographers.
i dont think the "rules" are as important as whether the photo looks good.
in #2 i cropped it exactly how i wanted it to, it wasnt just an accidental careless "amputation"
I wish the folks on this forum were more open minded about the fact that photography, like any other type of art is very subjective.
Are there ways to make photos better, of course. But better for who?
I like #2. I don't believe a critique is necessary for every response
I like the idea of these and if the posing suits the personality of the subject I'm sure she would love these.
The cropped limbs do bother me whether you intended it or not, but in the 3rd one the dark shadow really draws my eye :-(. It you intended for such a dark shadow that is fine, but I still find it distracting. Also I think it is slightly underexposed.
All in all though these are great in terms of colour and fun! I really like the 2nd one.
In terms of the other issues raised in this thread:
Here is the thing, it is kind of a given to me that when you post here you would actually like some feedback from your peers... I mean, If I wanted a "well done, these are FANTASTIC/AMAZING" I would show my photos to my mom
I think knowing the basics and the rules are imperative BEFORE you start breaking them. (Dangerwoman, not saying that you don't know the basics, just a general observation)
As photographers we need to strive to improve - even old pros will tell you that.
Anelle