Discussion in 'The Black & White Gallery' started by 92sir, Dec 27, 2008.
For me, both the vignette and the toning are overpowering the image.
The image is simple and nicely composed with the strong lead-in.
Sometimes less is better.
I really appreciate the critique. I have to agree the more I looked at it the more I really didnt like it. I have uploaded a different version hopefully this one is better. Thanks again for the comments.
I'll be honest, I think that if you wanted to take this image to print(and I believe it is indeed print worthy) you may want to go without any vignette at all. If you still like the idea of the vignette, then I think larger than your second version, but, less in strength. Hope this makes sense.
Thanks for the input it really is appreciated. I agree with the vignette. I was actually iffy when I re did it. I wasnt to sure if I liked it but I figured I would see what you thought Thanks again SympL:thumbup:
Separate names with a comma.