Well since we don't have a specific forum section for this and previous attmepts have not worked out well we are left with a gap in the forum. Essentaily its a way for one member to tell others that they want more than just a few hints, pointers and compliments. So here is my suggestion: Method of operation: members wishing to request for more indepth review of their photos place "PRO Critique Requested" in the title of thier post along with the general name of the thread itself. With that title added the member then can make the post as normal, but it must stick to the following outlines: 1) Only 1 - 3 photos are allowed in the thread first post and they are not allowed to make additional posts to promote other works - however after comments they are allowed to post the same photos as in the first post for the purposes of displaying alternative editings after comments made by other members. This is to remove the problem of a poster flooding the thread with too many photos for comment and it should be noted that a single photo is the prefered option. 2) The poster must also state the following information for each photo (as possible) in the thread - equipment used; settings on the camera (ISO, aperture, shutter speed, shooting mode, other settings eg mirror lockup and flash); general description of the shooting conditions; thought that went into the photo (grabshot - planned landscape - etc...) as well as their own views of the photo(s) submitted in addition to any thoughts on weaknesses and how they might improve the overall result themselves. This is to help then show that they are thinking about their photography and are also willing to put in effort to further their own understanding and not just waiting on handouts from other members. That done the member has thus flagged the post to the community at large - it does not ganratee a more indepth review nor does it exclude other forms of commenting on the photo - its is mearly an "offical" message to the forum members that the poster is after a more indepth assessment. That is the general outline for the idea that I have in mind - it will require that mods (and members using the report post command and NOT backseat moderationg) do keep an eye on posts made with this notation - to ensure that the post contains the required components from the OP - if they are not met then the member should be contacted and given time to edit thier post and failing that have the title edited so that the "PRO" aspect is removed. I also accept that the word "PRO" might be better changed to a more suitable word to reflect the nature of those who might post more indepth reviews. Well anyone got any thoughts?