Recommendation for a Macro Lens for Canon Rebel XT

[rip555]

Hi,

I need a macro lens for a Canon Rebel XT. What I will be using it for is taking some close-up product pictures. I would like a fixed length lens. What would be some good recommendations for a decent lens at an economical price?

I heard that Sigma makes a pretty decent lens. How much of a difference is there b/n 50 mm, 70mm, 105mm? I sell fishing rods and would like to show very good detail. Typically, I would be shooting b/n 6-18 inches away.

I found some answers at: http://thephotoforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=120123

If anybody has any more insight, that would be great.

Thanks,

Robert

 

[asfixiate]

What is your budget and what does economical mean to you?

 

[250Gimp]

If your shooting product the EFS 60 nacro may be a good choice. I have heard the Tamron & Sigma macro specific lenses are tack sharp as well.

 

[njm1216]

I love my Canon 60mm Macro. I always get great results with it.

 

[rip555]

I wouldn't like to spend past $300. The more I think about it, the more I think I want a 70 mm or 100mm prime. I think it will prove more versatile.

Am I in La la land for this pricepoint?

 

[Big Mike]

I've also heard great things about the EF-S 60mm macro.

 

[Big Mike]

By the way, the rule for images in your signature, is that they have to be less than 60 pixels high...yours is too big. Please change or remove it.
Thanks.