mysteryscribe
TPF Noob!
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2006
- Messages
- 6,071
- Reaction score
- 3
- Location
- in the middle of north carolina
- Website
- retrophotoservice.2ya.com
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
During lunch with my wife I gave the SUGGESTIONS part of this thread some thought. If the critique is for anyone to post and critique in as has suddenly become the feeling. Why not just say simply.
Post one image period.
If you post an image you agree to allow editing of that one image only.
If you say good job you have to explain why.
If you say it is crap you also have to explain why....
if you want to suggest changes feel free...
If you disagree with another person you must say why...
then when someone says I love this shot, you can simple ask well lois why do you love it. You don't really need a stamp, that makes the person giving the critique feel like they have been accused of a crime.
Now before the circled wagon group jumps on me that is a suggestion. It wouldnt have required the rolling out of a new forum or a committee meeting. On the implication that some people's critiques weren't suitable for the NEW IMPROVED thread.
I personally would not be bothered to see someone say I love this landscape the colors match my bathroom. If that is why they like it. The lady who liked it because it matched her bathroom is a potential customer to. Not just the Holiday inn motel chain.
Post one image period.
If you post an image you agree to allow editing of that one image only.
If you say good job you have to explain why.
If you say it is crap you also have to explain why....
if you want to suggest changes feel free...
If you disagree with another person you must say why...
then when someone says I love this shot, you can simple ask well lois why do you love it. You don't really need a stamp, that makes the person giving the critique feel like they have been accused of a crime.
Now before the circled wagon group jumps on me that is a suggestion. It wouldnt have required the rolling out of a new forum or a committee meeting. On the implication that some people's critiques weren't suitable for the NEW IMPROVED thread.
I personally would not be bothered to see someone say I love this landscape the colors match my bathroom. If that is why they like it. The lady who liked it because it matched her bathroom is a potential customer to. Not just the Holiday inn motel chain.