bogleric
TPF Noob!
This is a very good debate indeed. I tend to walk a fine line between the two sides. While I would not mind removing the stick from the water, I personally would not remove a tree or building. I try not to alter anything that effects the underlying substance. For example, adding trees, rapids in water, etc.
Overall I use photoshop to fix some of the small oop's that happen that you cannot just walk outside to fix.
Overall I use photoshop to fix some of the small oop's that happen that you cannot just walk outside to fix.