You guys have hit a nerve with me as well. Far be it for me to offer criticism to another photographer. I only know what I like and dislike not necessarily the mechanics behind my view point. My only way of showing what may be wrong with a shot that I care to offer an opinion on, is by experimenting in PS and then submitting it for the original member to judge. And now the board has decided to rule out editing???? With detailed actions from PS??? WRONG! You are not giving me and others a chance to voice our opinions in such a way we only know, were cut off at the knees and can not compete with the pros. Re-evaluate your strict rules . I am an amateurs amateur.