well, maybe this belongs in the dark side gallery ;)

Alex_B · Nov 23, 2006

.. and there it actually was posted ... but since nothing is going on there I post it here now.

critique most welcome!

oh, it was taken and processed by a friend of mine, she will be reading your comments

memorex88 · Nov 23, 2006

Well I know it’s a tree yet it’s a disturbing image. The red on there seems wrong IMO.

mysteryscribe · Nov 23, 2006

very interesting shot... I don't know whatelse to say oh yeah I like it

emogirl · Nov 23, 2006

disturbing, weird, but cool...kind of like it..

midnitejam · Nov 23, 2006

I find it dark, but I like it anyway.

oldnavy170 · Nov 23, 2006

Cool photo but what is that red stuff on the tree?

Steel26 · Nov 24, 2006

i would have like to have a little less of the darkness in the top right.

Alex_B · Nov 26, 2006

thanks for the comments

sthvtsh · Nov 26, 2006

Alex_B said:
thanks for the comments

Did you even read the comments? They asked questioned

Alex_B · Nov 26, 2006

it is not my picture, so I am not qualified to answer!

.. and there was only one real question, oldnavy knows I will answer her question at some point

.

BTW, I guess, that is just false colours with the red.

DLozada · Nov 26, 2006

It appears as though the duck/goose is flying away from some carcase...

but, I do like it though. it's kind-of perplexing. i like that the colors in the duck/goose are identical to the lake, although I think I would have made the green on his head and the orange of his beak stand out more.

fire999 · Nov 26, 2006

sthvtsh said:
Did you even read the comments? They asked questioned

Hi there,

I have only been a member here for 30 seconds,,, and in the last 30 mins all the post i have read........... have YOU complaining and critisising everyone... i have looked at you webb site, ATBH i think you had better check out your own pics before critisising others.. I would not normally say this . and i am surprised no one else has first .....

fire999 · Nov 26, 2006

:er: Alex B ..... Look above i was quoting the post before , it was not aimed at you .... :wink:

was meant for

sthvtsh

sthvtsh · Nov 30, 2006

fire999 said:
Hi there,

I have only been a member here for 30 seconds,,, and in the last 30 mins all the post i have read........... have YOU complaining and critisising everyone... i have looked at you webb site, ATBH i think you had better check out your own pics before critisising others.. I would not normally say this . and i am surprised no one else has first .....

Actually, I'm pretty sure it's the first time I've really complained like that.
Besides, The Photo Forum - Photography Discussion Forum > Foundations of Photography > Photo Critique