What looks better?

[bellacat]

I like the first much better but i really don't like that you took out the arm of the chair.

 

[Shibby!]

Here is a quick edit with the background darkened and saturation turned up a bit to make the skin feel warmer and the pink brighter.

Also some minor cloneing on her face.

Sorry about the quality.

 

[Wyjid]

Here's one without the chair, darkened background and reduced highlights on her face and shirt. Softened the skin a bit. used mask and brush and feathered the selected edges (3px). hope you like it.