what photo is better?

articsilber323 · Feb 19, 2007

cedew · Feb 19, 2007

When the composition is bad, it really wont matter what you try, it just wont happen. Was this tree inspiring to you?

qUAntUm k · Feb 19, 2007

in my opinion, with blue background is the better of the two. Against the blue, the dynamics of the tree's trunk and branches stand out.:thumbup:

articsilber323 · Feb 20, 2007

i just thought the tree was cool looking

Parago · Feb 20, 2007

cedew said:
When the composition is bad, it really wont matter what you try, it just wont happen. Was this tree inspiring to you?

What a weird question to ask. And what a rude way to say you don't like it. Maybe you need to learn about some basics such as 'art is always and foremost a matter of perception and personal preference'.

To say 'the composition is bad' is plain wrong, sorry. Just because it doesn't appeal to you doesn't mean it's wrong. I'd go even further an dsay there is no wrong or right when it comes to art.

Now what?

elsaspet · Feb 20, 2007

first is the best, but I'm a color freak.
Try a different perspective maybe?

cedew · Feb 20, 2007

The question was asked to serve as a reminder that photos taken should have some sort of meaning to the photographer, and not just wander around clicking at whatever. I didn't think it was rude, if it came off that way, my apologies to the thread starter.

My perception is that the composition is bad. The photo is being submitted for critique, and that is my opinion, I stand by it. I never said it was wrong, you brought that word into this discussion. The first rule in photography is that there are no rules, I live by this behind the lens.

Now what? Heck...I dunno, time for lunch?

Parago · Feb 20, 2007

cedew said:
The question was asked to serve as a reminder that photos taken should have some sort of meaning to the photographer, and not just wander around clicking at whatever. I didn't think it was rude, if it came off that way, my apologies to the thread starter.

My perception is that the composition is bad. The photo is being submitted for critique, and that is my opinion, I stand by it. I never said it was wrong, you brought that word into this discussion. The first rule in photography is that there are no rules, I live by this behind the lens.

Now what? Heck...I dunno, time for lunch?

Just as well. :mrgreen:

elsaspet · Feb 20, 2007

"#7 cedew vbmenu_register("postmenu_751844", true);
TPF Noob!

Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 11

My Photos Are OK to Edit

The question was asked to serve as a reminder that photos taken should have some sort of meaning to the photographer, and not just wander around clicking at whatever."

But did you ever take, much less share on a public forum, a photo that didn't speak to your heart? Obviously this one did, to the shooter.
To suggest that this is just a "click shot" is rude considering the shooter picked his/her favorite of the bunch.
You don't have to love it, but a little TLC goes a hell of a long way.
Sometimes, you can't reshoot, so maybe offer how to make the photo better using editing.
Just a suggestion.
Still like the shot, BTW.

elsaspet · Feb 20, 2007

Furthermore..............
Ugg, this was just the type of thing I was going on about yesterday. Poster with 11 posts, no website, no photo posts, talking about how much "this" photo sucks.
My opinion is, if you can do it better, do it, and then show it, in a nice way, to show how to better the photo. Not some glib crap about lunchtime. That speaks to, and informs, noone.
Sorry to jack the thread, but this HAS to stop.

elsaspet · Feb 20, 2007

And BTW, I STILL like the shot. Don't let folks get you down. You did something differently, processed it well, and had the courage to ask us our opinion.
Personally, I think it's great. (#1 of course, 'cause I'm a color freak)
Keep on going! You are on the right track.

LaFoto · Feb 20, 2007

(

Pssst Elsaspet: Cedew did post a photo of his own, here .)

elsaspet · Feb 20, 2007

You are right LaFoto. Nice shot as well. I like the comp.
But still..............how to help, not to discourage, is EVERYTHING.

Love ya Lady!

Antarctican · Feb 20, 2007

I echo the above comments of Elsaspet. I like the shot (and I too prefer the colour version). The comments provided by Cedew were not informative or constructive and whether it was intended or not, they were rather harshly worded. Articsilber323, please do NOT be discouraged from posting...you're doing fine. I for one look forward to seeing more of your images.