Which eye do you think is better processed?

[hamlet]

What eye do you think is better processed, or could use more or less editing? All tips welcome.

This is all 1:1 cropped and taken with a 50mm and my d3200.


The usual global image sharpened:

Eye specifically sharpened and brightened a bit

Non-sharpened special high pass filter edit

 

[Santa_Claus]

Maybe it's just viewing it on the ipad, but there is negligible difference I can see. The reflections in 2 are a bit crisper, but I can't imagine that being very apparent on even a 30" portrait.

 

[CameraClicker]

I like #2, but only because the iris is slightly darker. I think they are all pretty close.

 

[hamlet]

Thank you folks, i like the second one too.

 

[TheStig]

On my phone, the third looks best, but I wouldn't stress it too much. There isn't a huge difference between them.

 

[ShermanAng]

All 3 very close. U must really hunt for the different. But I like 2

 

[Josh66]

Each one looks different to me (progressing from meh to good) - the last one looks the best to me. Except that the reflection in the eye is also the brightest in the last one...