Wide angle lens for DX

[slquoue]

I am buying a budget DX wide angle lens for my Nikon D5100 for an upcoming trip to Andalucia, Spain.

I'm torn between two versatile choices - the Sigma 10-20 or the Tokina 12-28. Any advice?

I know the Tokina 11-16 is highly recommended but for me it's just not versatile enough.

Any advice much appreciated!

 

[ruifo]

I'd go with the Tokina AT-X 11-20mm f/2.8 PRO DX

 

[SCraig]

Sigma 17-70

 

[gckless]

I don't have experience with either of your choices, but I will throw in the Sigma 8-16mm to the mix as another choice.

Are you looking for a specific focal length, or just a good range?