Zion National Park

[WillK]

I took a panorama HDR over Weeping Rock. I want to know which version you like better and why?

To me, 2 and 4 seems to bring out more emotion. Like it's a new world, a sense of greatness. Almost like a painting too. an abstract world kinda theme.

1 and 3 seem realistic but it doesn't seem to pop as much as the first picture.

 

[Light Guru]

2 and 4 are EXTREMELY overdone they have more forced or fake emotion that natural emotion.

1 and 2 have vary distracting foregrounds.

3 is the best of the 4 but it is still a overdone in the processing.

 

[Dikkie]

I've been to the America's once in 2008, and visited Zion NP too.
Personally, I like nature shots more naturally. I dislike it to have it overcooked in HDR.
If you like it that way, keep it.

Still... Zion is a very nice park, my own pictures didn't came out that well, but as compensation, I have enjoyed the nature and have good memories to it, hiking the rocks:

Certainly want to go back there once upon a time...