b&w's and a swan, opinions please

[liquidflight]

I'd like to hear what you all think of these, be honest. I know that there are some points that could use work, but I'd like to hear each different opinion.

 

[terri]

A nice collection. #1 would have more visual impact for me if the tree weren't quite so dead center. Beautiful image, a little cropping could fix that. Very stark and dramatic, my kinda shot! #2 - almost there; I want more texture in the boards to go with the shadows and angles...ALMOST there, but it's not quite grabbing me. #3 seems a little falt, but that could be my monitor, too, although I like the image. I like your swan: maybe a half stop or so off in exposure? Again, could be my monitor, but I'd like a little more detail in the beak. If it's there, it's just my old monitor telling lies.

Nice work, overall! #1 is my fave despite the composition.

 

[vonnagy]

mmm, number one is awesome. it even looks like the tree seperates the black and white from from the clouds! cool shot liquidflight! very cool.
Cheers!

 

[Geronimo]

1.I think if the tree in number one was off set to the left, inside the lighted area it would add a striking feeling to it imo.

2. A little more detail would be nice.

3. I like it.