black and white or colour?

[clickityclick]

Can i get some feed back on this shot, black and white or colour, scroll down to see two versions..... I think its a bit flat and I think i overdid it in colour saturation in PS (the colour one) let me know

 

[icassell]

Yes


(actually, the images aren't coming up here for some reason -- just thought the question was interesting).

 

[Bifurcator]

Here it is... You might want to edit the original message with the correct links. Might make it more readable.

On the image itself. It's not over saturated. But it is fuzzy. I guess there was camera shake or motion that made it all blurry.

So for me at least neither grey nor color are working. Sorry, hope that doesn't sound too harsh.

 

[clickityclick]

 

[clickityclick]

not at alll all feedback welocme thank you.. I see the camera shake too. I thought I might get away with it in the grey, that grainy atmospheric effect!