tkaat
TPF Noob!
- Joined
- May 27, 2008
- Messages
- 307
- Reaction score
- 0
- Location
- On a Island
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
I think you can achieve great results with both methods. Many people think that a B&W scanned negative printed with a printer does not have the same quality as a well printed silver image ('enlarger method'). Moreover, I am not so sure that the scanner/printer method would be cheaper than the enlarger method. To achieve good results with a scanner, you need a good scanner, probably a calibrated monitor and a good printer (consumable such as inks and paper are not that cheap). On the other hand enlargers are dirt cheap at the moment (have a look on eBay).
Even though I was the one who posted that digital would be cheaper after seeing how much it really cost the manual way is the cheaper of the two :blushing:
But the thing is you don't know how much longer they will be producing film developing supplies (but I personally think that will be in 10 maybe 30 hopefully) so I would go with the manual (enlarger method) and try it while you still have the chance cause it seems those who have done it really love the experience and it is a good trait for a photographer to know especially a film photographer.