Feedback photoshop

[Blue804]

Hey i would love to get some feedback on a photo i edited in photoshop. Im just trying to learn more and more about photoshop to get better. The photo is taken with a bad old camera and i just tryed to improve it a bit. How do you think it went? Pretty new with this stuff so please let me know what you think and i appreciate all tips and fixes.
And by the way, would this photo make it in any microstock sites?

AFTER

BEFORE

 

[Braineack]

besides removing the date stamp, I'd have done that in LR. IMHO, simple processing is not the job of PS.

 

[Blue804]

Ah okey, never tried lightroom before might give it a try then.

 

[SCraig]

Way over-sharpened. Look how much more jagged the edges of the guardrail and road are.

 

[Blue804]

Way over-sharpened. Look how much more jagged the edges of the guardrail and road are.

Yeah was thinking about that but diden't know for sure. Thanks for the tip, i will change that.

 

[Rick58]

Ouch,,.Agree with Scott. This one hurts my eyes. How about something like this...

 

[Blue804]

Looks awesome, Did you use photoshop?

 

[Rick58]

I have CS2 and Lightroom, but I like Paint Shop Pro. Probably only because I'm more familar with it. I pulled some detail out of the sky, tweaked the foreground brightness and contrast, then hit it with a little fill light to brighten the stones

 

[Ysarex]

I used Photoshop.

Joe

 

[Blue804]

Thanks for the awesome replys, I got so much more to learn.

 

[Rick58]

One photo at a time. My post processing is really inferior to most on here. The important thing is to keep it fun.

 

[Blue804]

Yeah i guess youre right. Fun gets priority 1.

 

[DavefromCt]

Hey i would love to get some feedback on a photo i edited in photoshop. Im just trying to learn more and more about photoshop to get better. The photo is taken with a bad old camera and i just tryed to improve it a bit. How do you think it went? Pretty new with this stuff so please let me know what you think and i appreciate all tips and fixes.
And by the way, would this photo make it in any microstock sites?

AFTER
View attachment 90794 BEFOREView attachment 90795

It looks oversharpened on my monitor.

 

[DavefromCt]

Hey i would love to get some feedback on a photo i edited in photoshop. Im just trying to learn more and more about photoshop to get better. The photo is taken with a bad old camera and i just tryed to improve it a bit. How do you think it went? Pretty new with this stuff so please let me know what you think and i appreciate all tips and fixes.
And by the way, would this photo make it in any microstock sites?

AFTER
View attachment 90794 BEFOREView attachment 90795

How about this?

Hey i would love to get some feedback on a photo i edited in photoshop. Im just trying to learn more and more about photoshop to get better. The photo is taken with a bad old camera and i just tryed to improve it a bit. How do you think it went? Pretty new with this stuff so please let me know what you think and i appreciate all tips and fixes.
And by the way, would this photo make it in any microstock sites?

AFTER
View attachment 90794 BEFOREView attachment 90795

How about this try?

 

[Blue804]

View attachment 90864

Hey i would love to get some feedback on a photo i edited in photoshop. Im just trying to learn more and more about photoshop to get better. The photo is taken with a bad old camera and i just tryed to improve it a bit. How do you think it went? Pretty new with this stuff so please let me know what you think and i appreciate all tips and fixes.
And by the way, would this photo make it in any microstock sites?

AFTER
View attachment 90794 BEFOREView attachment 90795

How about this?

Hey i would love to get some feedback on a photo i edited in photoshop. Im just trying to learn more and more about photoshop to get better. The photo is taken with a bad old camera and i just tryed to improve it a bit. How do you think it went? Pretty new with this stuff so please let me know what you think and i appreciate all tips and fixes.
And by the way, would this photo make it in any microstock sites?

AFTER
View attachment 90794 BEFOREView attachment 90795

How about this try?

Looks really good, did you use PS?