What exactly are you taking pictures of? Are you taking pics of the interior of the church itself or something like a wedding?
In either case, you will want to use a tripod. If you are taking interior shots, you might want to try HDR (high dynamic range imaging) where you set the aperture, then take about 5 shots at various shutter speeds, so that you get 5 shots at different levels of exposure (e.g., -2, -1, 0, +1, +2). From there, you can put them all together in Photoshop and it will merge them so that each aspect of the pic is properly exposed. I think you must be able to shoot in RAW for this though.
If you are doing some wedding shots (or similar) I would say up adjust your settings until you can maintain at least a shutter speed of 1/125. That will involve a combination of going to the wider apertures and higher film speeds. The trade off is that you will get some digital grain, but you could remove that with some NR software like neat image. An external strobe flash would help loads if permitted.
Maybe make your question a little more specific.