How was my editing?

Before:




After:









I know I have some flaws but overall I think I did a pretty good job. I probably added too much saturation but oh well.

 

Definately better than before. I think it's a little too bold and you might be right......a little less saturation might be better. I think that the with PP you shouldn't be able to tell that it was edited......that's unless you go all out for a really different look.

I also think a tall crop would look good. Maybe the entire height and for width to the right side of the dog and left side just to the left of the tree. Might see how it looks like that.

 

Yeah, that is some good PhotoShop work for sure! You should crop some off of the left side (and other sides, just not as drastically) to close in on your subject a bit more. Good colors and exposure and focus. Nice shot. And good PS work!

 

better, but you overdid the sharpness and saturation a lot.

 

I would like to see more doggie, less droopy tree - get closer next time and you won't need to edit so much. It's definitely improved though.

 

Thanks for the comments! I really appreciate it.

If you guys ever want me to comment on one of your threads go ahead and PM me the link and I'll post there.