Pssst... Wanna have some fun?

[abraxas]

This could be interesting. We're all big boys and girls here aren't we? How about the following for a little entertainment?

Let's critique YOUR critiques!

Post a link to your very, very, very best, finished critique!!!!

AND THEN,... WE'LL ALL CRITIQUE IT!!!!

This, I believe, will help us improve our critical skills and make for an all encompassing learning experience!!!

Volunteers?

Have you had any critiques committed on your photos that you'd like analyzed?

-

 

[Emerana]

holy moly you are stuck on this topic

there it is my best c&c, have at it

 

[abraxas]

Anyway, I'm going to go ahead and link up to one that from observation seems to have gone pretty well.

I think it's interesting to note, that not only was C&C requested, it is the title of the thread.

Here's the request:
http://www.thephotoforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=127809

Here's the response that impressed me.
http://www.thephotoforum.com/forum/showthread.php?p=1284430#post1284430

Is there anything I missed?

Are there any other thoughts on this?

 

[Overread]

You know I actually like this idea. There are many here whos voice I respect because they have shown time and time again that they know their stuff. I have commented where I can as best as I can and yet there are times that I do wonder if I am passing on the right advice or presenting the whole picture as it should be done so I would be intersted in the views of others as to this.
I also think this could be a great way to get some additional advice about certain specific situations - I say if your crit gets some good comments then post a link back to the thread it came from - that way the OP you were helping before can read the views of some others on matters

 

[abraxas]

You know I actually like this idea. ...

It's not over.

Check it out and critique the critique.

 

[tirediron]

I think this is an excellent idea! It's easy to critique, but not so easy to critique effectively. Especially for those of us (*Looks in mirror*) who offer up a lot of critique/comment anything that can be learned on how to improve the advice and suggestions we offer others is valuable!

Thanks for thinking of this,
John

 

[Alpha]

Post #5 here:
http://thephotoforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=100805

 

[kundalini]

Good idea. Can't say that I have given a good critique, but I'll try and find an accurate one.

 

[christopher walrath]

Sorry, folks. Not this bored yet.

 

[kundalini]

After much reviewing and interspeculation, it has been determined that I give neither good or accurate critiques.

Anyone that has received a post of mine is well advised to simply ignore that entry. There is no need for arguement, because I am wrong, haven't a clue of my understanding of the subject and can't tell my a$$ from a hole in the ground.

Thank you in advance for your understanding in this matter.

 

[abraxas]

After much reviewing and interspeculation, it has been determined that I give neither good or accurate critiques.

Anyone that has received a post of mine is well advised to simply ignore that entry. There is no need for arguement, because I am wrong, haven't a clue of my understanding of the subject and can't tell my a$$ from a hole in the ground.

Thank you in advance for your understanding in this matter.

So,... you're saying it ain't over?- Cool.

Hey, what'd you think about:
http://www.thephotoforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=127343

Are bludgeoning opinions 'in' now-a-days?