skieur
TPF Noob!
- Joined
- May 14, 2007
- Messages
- 5,071
- Reaction score
- 204
- Location
- Canada
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
Post it here. I'd be happy to do it for you. Just make sure to check back to see the critique.
The method is simple. Just post your photo here the same you would in any other thread, and I'll quote it in my critique of the photo. Be prepared, though. I won't be merciful, no matter the level of beginner.
The only rules:
NO LINKS
Please limit your posts to 3 photos
Please limit your amount of active posts to 1. That is, do not post another set of photos until the previous has been assessed.
I look forward to seeing your photos. :mrgreen:
Thanks for stopping by.
Mark
To be brutally honest about critiquing the critiques, you are taking a very limited, emotional approach to whether the shot says anything to you. "Professional" critiquing involves the technical side: You did not notice mention of over or under-exposure, camera angle, depth of field etc. and the one suggestion about wide angle would have flattened the shot in a negative way. Only one comment about editing and that was very vague. No suggestions about how to improve any of the images in post. A more thorough critique of the technical side is warranted on some shots.
Composition needs to be evaluated in a more specific way including the visual effect (positive or negative) of shape, colour, texture, lighting etc. or the position of the picture elements and whether a better placement was possible. You did not use the term: centre of interest, either, and the fact that at least one image did not have one and that the centre of interest must have some level of visual impact for the viewer. A clichee shot for example is often one with a boring centre of interest that requires a more original approach from the photographer.
These are just a very few pointers. There are many more.
You provided a few comments but definitely not a critique.
skieur