St. Augustine's College

[Alpha]

6x9 negative. Don't remember what the film was...probably PanF.

 

[New England Moments]

Well you got it in the right forum... cause it is truly Black, and truly White..

No in betweens/ speechless !

 

[Alex_B]

the foreground i a bit too dark for my taste. if the shiluette was more interesting, that strong contrast might work, but now one has the feeling that there are more interesting structures hidden in the dark ...

this is just personal taste of course.

 

[Alpha]

nah it's not personal taste, it's technically correct commentary. It's been a long time since I've seen the negative for this one...was scanned back before I got the super coolscan. Not that that's any excuse necessarily. I just cant remember how I scanned it and whether or not there was any PP done.

 

[The_Traveler]

What were you attempting to do with this picture?

 

[abraxas]

Are you looking for critique or just sharing? Is this image OTE?

I've never been to NC, is this what schools are like there?

 

[New England Moments]

OTE ???? What is this??

 

[abraxas]

OTE ???? What is this??

OK to edit

 

[New England Moments]

Max edited??? you can't be serious, your messing with perfection...

Would you re paint the Mona Lisa ??

 

[abraxas]

Max edited??? you can't be serious, your messing with perfection...

Would you re paint the Mona Lisa ??

I'd probably wipe the smirk off her face ( )...

I didn't see 'OTE' in Leonardo's profile though, so I'll leave it alone and comment in text.

 

[Alpha]

What were you attempting to do with this picture?

I was attempting to create a picture with this picture.

 

[The_Traveler]

I was attempting to create a picture with this picture.

I don't understand why you chose this as an example of your ability.

Well it seems that your expertise has failed you.

You dramatically underexposed a dark building against a flat/bright sky, the perpendiculars converge in a non-interesting way and you seem to have chosen a very boring building.

 

[mysteryscribe]

Max I always say when they ask me, what i was trying to do?
"Get rid of those last two frames on the roll." It's just a matter of principle with me.

 

[Alex_B]

why you chose this as an example of your ability.

well, I am not sure that was his intent.

I often post images on here where I am unsure, ...

 

[The_Traveler]

well, I am not sure that was his intent.

I often post images on here where I am unsure, ...

I was giving him the benefit of the doubt, that there had actually been some thought behind it.