the b&w doesn't have enough visual impact to carry itself on it's own, i don't think. i can't tell what that mountain of blob is... the captured texture and shape doesn't let me "figure it out" either, so it's a miss.
the color version however has lots of interesting color although those smooth strawberry things (not the sugar coated one) concentrates too much red into the image. perhaps if you had more of the green tops showing it would help break it up a bit?
something else that niggles at me (is that even a word? niggle?) is the sugar coated strawberry that is out of focus in the foreground. everything else seems to be in focus at that plane except the front part of the strawberry... even the strawberry on top of it is focused throughout. so the lack of focus on the frontal plane bothers me.