When C&C is requested.

terri · May 11, 2009

Anubis said:
Another idea may be an invite only/hidden board where people who offer sensible and helpful critique in the main forums are invited to join. Much the same way I imagine moderators are chosen. Then you would have a C&C forum without the "bad eggs" which in turn would probably lead to more stuff being posted in that forum ...rewarding people who make the effort to contribute.

Again....it's a "Group", using the existing features of this vB application, and it can be member-driven and member-controlled.

Guys, you're doing a whole lot of talking but no organizing.

You seem to want the moderators to design something that, in reality, can more readily be approached and controlled by YOU. After prior moderator-guided attempts (that ultimately failed), I strongly believe you will collectively be happier if you design and run your own critique area. I repeat - one of you only take the initiative to start a user's group here for C&C, and invite a few people to lay out your own guidelines. There should be no heavy-handed moderator involvement needed, unless there is a violation of basic TPF guidelines, which is not likely.

I encourage you all to go for it.