Which one?

ShutteredEye · Oct 27, 2005

Which of the 3 do you like. (I'd especially like to hear from those of you with color corrected monitors.)

1.

2.

3.

JonK · Oct 27, 2005

My monitor is calibrated. I voted for #3. The first is too cool. the second and third are very close but the second seems a tad more on the red side.
client will probably prefer a warm version over a cool one.

Christie Photo · Oct 28, 2005

I confess my monitor has not been calibrated, but from experience, I believe it's rather close. I agree with Jon that the warmer views are preferalbe. I think the softening on #3 is a benifit... it somehow helps with the overexposure.

-Pete

ShutteredEye · Oct 28, 2005

Here's pretty much my final edit. Any last minute suggestions?

LittleMan · Oct 28, 2005

mountainlander said:
Here's pretty much my final edit. Any last minute suggestions?

hmmm, this last one seems to be a bit too dark... The blacks are too overpowering, especially in her hair.
I would suggest going with the one that Jon suggested. Maybe slightly darker but I think this last one is a bit too dark.

Great shot btw! :thumbup:

Vmann · Nov 1, 2005

The third looks a little two blurred in spots... looks like smart blur was used. I would replicate the layer before bluring and give the hands, arms and some of the other pieces back some detail with a mask. Just my .02