Which Version? (nudity - not safe for work)

[Efergoh]

Up late...lots of editing...

I like all three of these, but can't decide which one I should run with. Give me a hand here, would ya?

Nude shots...cubical critters beware...

Version 1

Version 2

Version 3

 

[Efergoh]

opps. This was supposed to go to Critique...
Will a Mod move it for me?

 

[TBaraki]

I like the first the most. The soft colours and the background gradation really pull it together.

 

[PNA]

#2 has nice shadows and backlighting

 

[newrmdmike]

i like the first and second best.

the only thing that bothers me is that i can see part of her tatoo, not all of it.

 

[RedDevilUK]

#2 for me
although, im not a big fan of shadows (each to there own)
but i would prefer a second light source on the right, and another object... so she looks like she is looking at something?

having said that... i think the lighting on all 3 is ok... i would of prefered 3 choices of angles, maybe more to the left, this shot and then more to the right.

the shot a little more to the left, would make newrmdmike happy as he would see more of the tattoo

but i definatly think we need to see the object of her desire...

all of the above is just my opinion, and i hope it helps.... your obviously a good photographer.
but another opinion never does any harm

PS. Great looking model.

 

[Puscas]

I prefer #2. :thumbup:
The tatoo looks fine to me. The only thing I don't like is that there's not a lot of space between the sheet and the bottom border. I don't know why, but that bothers me.






pascal

 

[heip]

I like 1&2 equally. #3 still works, but I prefer the lit background on the others. Nice work!!

 

[gmarquez]

Another vote for two..It almost looks like an airbrushed painting, or like a statue carved out of alabaster.

 

[Aquarium Dreams]

I prefer number one. I love the color of her skin and hair, and the smoothness of her skin doesn't come across in black and white as well, imo.

 

[morydd]

I'm going to throw a vote for #2 as well. I'll also agree with the comment that I'd like to see more of the tattoo or none of it. (on the other hand, I like tattoos, but not on women in general. Gilding the lily)

The shadow on her left arm bugs me a little bit. It comes out as a straight line, and the only straight line in the image.

 

[Andrew T. Mironov]

#2 for me

 

[reshp1]

2, followed closely by 1. I don't like 3, the shadows on her melt and merge into the background too much. The gradient is more interesting anyway.

 

[ashfordphoto]

2

 

[boogaguy]

All three are quality but personally iI prefer #3.
The black into which she sort of melts has an unknown menace which contrasts perfectly with her soft beauty.

You know what they say about opinions......