- Joined
- Jun 9, 2013
- Messages
- 20,580
- Reaction score
- 12,709
- Website
- moderndinosaur.wordpress.com
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos NOT OK to edit
I've had this question forming in my mind for a couple of weeks and it might finally be ready. It started when I realized that there's yet another "Us vs Them" rift amongst us shutterbugs: Flash vs Natural Light. I know all too well the Film vs Digital debate, and of course there's the Canon vs Nikon feud, the Pro vs Amateur, the Auto vs Manual, the Cut The Head vs Don't Cut The Head, yadda yadda yadda.
I was quite surprised to hear such derogatory comments about "natural light photographers" - they are afraid to learn, they're only pretending to have a preference for natural light because they're too clueless to use a flash, they're snotty about 'flashers'...As someone who tends to shoot with available light, I probably should have been peeved, but I was too curious about it all to even think of being offended.
Instead, I started wondering: why don't I use flash? I can see how it's useful and necessary in some situations, but they all seem to be situations that I don't take pictures of. But why not? Why am I interested in the things I take pictures of? I do notice light and how it falls on a subject, but for some reason, it never occurs to me to manipulate that light.
Anywhooooo, without blathering on for much longer, the whole thing made me want to ask everyone this question: what attracts you to the kind of pictures you like to take? Why portraits? Why birds? Why macro? Why landscapes? (you get the idea)...what makes you interested in those things?
I do NOT want to incite any repeats of the above feuds. I don't want to read things like "I do X because Y pictures are lame" or "Pictures should represent reality/not represent reality". I mean, I do like and take pictures that more reflect reality, but I don't think all pictures should be that way. It's just a preference that dictates how and what I shoot and I would never expect others to feel or do the same. So let's leave the judgments out of this and not should all over each other
So, no picking sides on any debates or picking on styles or types that you are not attracted to. Just stating what you do like about the kinds of pictures you take. Just what you like to shoot and why, and no worrying about anyone else's style or preferences.
Who wants to go first?
I was quite surprised to hear such derogatory comments about "natural light photographers" - they are afraid to learn, they're only pretending to have a preference for natural light because they're too clueless to use a flash, they're snotty about 'flashers'...As someone who tends to shoot with available light, I probably should have been peeved, but I was too curious about it all to even think of being offended.
Instead, I started wondering: why don't I use flash? I can see how it's useful and necessary in some situations, but they all seem to be situations that I don't take pictures of. But why not? Why am I interested in the things I take pictures of? I do notice light and how it falls on a subject, but for some reason, it never occurs to me to manipulate that light.
Anywhooooo, without blathering on for much longer, the whole thing made me want to ask everyone this question: what attracts you to the kind of pictures you like to take? Why portraits? Why birds? Why macro? Why landscapes? (you get the idea)...what makes you interested in those things?
I do NOT want to incite any repeats of the above feuds. I don't want to read things like "I do X because Y pictures are lame" or "Pictures should represent reality/not represent reality". I mean, I do like and take pictures that more reflect reality, but I don't think all pictures should be that way. It's just a preference that dictates how and what I shoot and I would never expect others to feel or do the same. So let's leave the judgments out of this and not should all over each other
So, no picking sides on any debates or picking on styles or types that you are not attracted to. Just stating what you do like about the kinds of pictures you take. Just what you like to shoot and why, and no worrying about anyone else's style or preferences.
Who wants to go first?