Which One?

[Clear Black]

This is a 2 part thread. First I would like some general feedback on the image, and then maybe a consensus on which version is more appealing. I'm certainly a novice at photography in general, so please don't hold back on the comments.

Version 1:

Version 2:

 

[ladykrae]

I like #2 better. The apple stands out nicely. Good job!

 

[The Phototron]

Provide us with a larger version.

For now, I like number 1 better, the soft glow is fitting.

 

[spiffybeth]

version 2

 

[Renair]

#1

So now it is a tie, better put larger images up so we can see better, I like 1 because the girl looks out of focus a little but the selective colouring of the apple becomes the focus.....:thumbup:

 

[ilyfel]

Neither.. but if i had to pic 2

 

[The Phototron]

I guess I have to clone myself and put in another vote for 1.

Btw, keep the eye sharp in number 1.

Number 1, get it?!

 

[nealjpage]

Version 2 I like better.

But I dislike selective coloring.

 

[Stillwater]

I dig #2 better, the less blurry hands don't hurt my eyes when I'm trying to focus on the apple.

But I dislike selective coloring.

As do I.