My favorite is #2, totally captures the moment and the feeling.
#1 is a bit offputting because the the defensive man's feet are in such an odd position that they take attention from the runner.
#3,4,5 are not nearly at the level of #2. Ok to set the scene but more filler than star.
Thanks Lee-Ann. It is a heck of a lot easier to shoot from the sideline than the stands. I have just been fortunate enough to have access to two local high-schools.
IMO, what is missing in #5 is the opponent. It could easily be a setup shot. There is no tension between us and them.
#2 gets so many feelings, the lineman tussling with each other, the runner staring intently, trying to find a space. It has it all.
It does have a bit of defect, that haloing from sharpening.
(at the arrows).
But that can be avoided. Just sharpen the face and let everything else go, if there is any blur that adds to the emotion.
Looks like your skills are getting better with more practice and more "reps". I think the color version of the photo is much better, has more impact, than the B&W version.
@The_Traveler, I went back in and masked out the halo around the running back. (There is still a few spots that are bright but it's not from sharpening.) Thanks for the catching that one.