Before and after(cloneing edit)does it work?(3 pics)

[chris82]

Heres a shot I took a few weeks ago!I croped it.Then I noticed there were a few areals and trees that I didnt like so I cloned them out.Does it look ok to you,thanks for looking.

1)Original.

2)Croped.

3)Croped and cloned.

Thanks again.

 

[gizmo2071]

I actually like the trees in this shot, not the aerial tho.
But nice job on the removal.

 

[chris82]

Cheers mate,heres one with the trees but no areal.

 

[LaFoto]

The last of With-Trees-But-Without-Aerial shows a couple of cloning artefacts but other than that you did a good job!

I can clone things out of a uniform sky, too, but that is about the extent to which I can do the job ... Azuth did a super cloning job for me in the Photoshop Challenges, now that was some dedication of his side. Way cool!

 

[chris82]

do you have the link of theat cloning job lafoto

 

[LaFoto]

Sure do! Here_it_is .

 

[chris82]

I found it thanks,Thats an amazing job he did,You woulgnt think there was a post there to begin with.And well done on the fhoto aswell.

 

[lostprophet]

the last one works for me

 

[BoblyBill]

I (personally) don't like the crop... great photoshopping (other than cloning artifacts) I think if you just get rid of the Aerial in the uncropped version. Just my humble opinion... Actually looking back over the picture I do like the crop better... LOL
so... never mind...LOL

 

[ClarkKent]

I like the uncropped version better. I think that the trees are ok in this, but maybe I would clone out the areals. Nice work!