Bethlehem Steel Stacks

[Nittany]

I am new to photography and newer to editing. I have been playing with Photoshop CS2 to work on some photos from the Bethlehem Steel Stacks. Here is a before and after. How did I do? What would you have done?

Before:

After:

Before:

After:

Before:

After:

 

[Designer]

Since they're not labeled, which ones are the "before" and which ones are the "after"?

 

[Nittany]

Labels added

 

[Designer]

What would you have done?

I would have tried to keep some detail in the shade and shadow areas, and maybe not so heavy on the color saturation.