What's new

Burnout, parts 1 & 2

the first one is my favorite, because it really tells the story in a clever and funny way, while still retaining the emotion of the woman on the pamphlet. again, im lovin this.
 
Number one is realllllly a great fit of the sign to the people. The second one is a "technique shot" that I've seen done countless times over decades, and it doesn't really rise above the level of normal to me. #1 OTOH, is really a nice shot to look at.
 
It is fascinating how experienced photographers compare these two different interpretations of the same idea... Some completely opposite views here.

I can not choose between the two, I guess the first image appeals to an analitycal/expressionist eye, whereas the second caters for impressionist tastes.

Correct me if I am wrong.
 
Here is the way I think of these two photos:

Shot #1 is PACKED with people, all preparing to go down to the subway system. In that mass of people ALMOST every one has downcast eyes....looking at the image, I quickly count six people who are looking up; the vast majority appear downcast with their eyes...synonymous with pressure, with the "rat-race", with being beaten down, and so on. The sign on the left is a literal...sign, about dealing with burnout. The Number 73 bus behind the crowd, moving on angle, toward the edge of the frame, adds an element of urban life, an element of your country with the red color and the specific bus style...we are literally being shown a modern, crowded, urban scene, and the majority of the people in the prime viewing spots are all shown looking downward. It's a very visual feast! I really like the people with the downcast eyes, seen in the context of "burnout".

The second shot lacks the tightly-packed crowd, lacks the bus, lacks the feeling of crowded-ness, and lacks the extremely cramped, hustle and bustle feel in large part because the entire background area is open, all the way back to the buildings. The people are blurred...mere suggestions of faces, impressionistic...it has no connotation of "burnout" whatsoever, whereas the first shot literally shows a sign that has the word burnout in it. The first shot matches the title, where the second is just a coattail-rider that has absolutely no connotation whatsoever of "burnout" within the image, but perhaps it does in your mind. The second one might just as easily be called "hurrying", or "blurry subway riders", or "the flow of urban commuters", or "ebb and flow", or whatever. I see the first one as a good image that uses a sign, and people, in an allegorical way that makes sense, while the second one is just a slow shutter speed on moving people...
 
Thanks Derrel, this is a very interesting explanation and I think it is a highly analytical or at least an expressionist approach with its usual attention to details that together create the whole picture.
I agree with what you have said about the first image, but interestingly you have not mentioned one important thing to me, that had nothing to do with details - the colour. I have desaturated this image to make people look pale or worn or tired. But here we step into the impressionist realm, aren't we?

It would be as interesting to hear why Gary A. prefers the second image... Let's hope he will find a minute or two...
 
The color in the second one just looked like incandescent lighting and slightly wonky white balance due to a mix of late afternoon/early evening light and artificial light sources. The color in the first one looks more color-accurate, the second one looks wonky. To me, the color of the first shot doesn't matter much...it's almost entirely the way that almost the entire crowd has downcast eyes...no eye contact with the camera, nor with one another...the color isn't much of a factor for me, it's the actual body language, and the similarity, the sameness, that the people exhibit.
 
The colour for the second one is completely arbitrary - post processed one, it was actually dark and I have raised the exposure in pp. And btw, regarding the name for the 2nd image, it is now officially The Ghosts of the Rush Hour :biggrin:
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom