What's new

Canon T4i with EF-S 18-135mm f/3.5-5.6 IS STM Lens - Background Focus Problem

ipinotti

TPF Noob!
Joined
May 9, 2013
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Location
Porto Alegre - Brazil
Can others edit my Photos
Photos OK to edit
Hello!

I am new to the forum, and new to DSLR cameras too...

I bought last month a Canon T4i with EF-S 18-135mm... Till that day, I always used point and shoot cameras...

So, I am still learning how to use my dslr. But I do have a doubt, or maybe a problem... Since I bought the camera, I started to use the automatic/intelligent mode, to shoot a wide variety of scenes. But I am having an issue about taking pictures of a person with the background appearing in the photo...

In point and shoot cameras, you just point and it's there, the person and the background focused and well defined as well...

In my T4i, in the automatic/intelligent mode, when I do the same thing, the background that the person is, became kinda blurry in the photo... The person in the photo appear well defined and focused, but the background does not... Is it right? Even in the automatic mode? Am I doing something wrong?

Thanks in advance
 
What you are asking about all depends on your f-stop. In full auto mode it sets it all for you and it seems right. If you want everything in focus you want f/11-f/16 set on the camera.

I recommend putting the camera in manual mode and suing around with it. You will then see what different f-stops can do as far as depth of field.

Also do research on camera ISO, shutter speed, and aperture.

A good book for a starting point is "understanding exposure". It's a great book for just starting out with dslr's. you can get it on amazon for like 15$ I think.

It will teach you how to be more creative with your exposure settings also (ISO, shutter speed, and aperture)

Here is a small image to help you see aperture of lenses.

$image-872116356.webp

The smaller the aperture (higher number) makes it so you can have more in focus and "sharp"

I hope this helps.
 
Hello JohnTrav,

I do understand that I have to study more about the photography features... but my concern is that, in automatic mode, is it right that the camera behave like this? Should it behave like a point and shoot in a portrait photo (a person in a background, without blurring the background)? Is it a problem with the camera?

Thanks
 
Automatic mode does all the thinking for you by taking the whole scene into consideration then sets what it thinks is the proper shutter speed,aperture and ISO for the proper exposure. It is probably taking the closest subject priority,meaning it locks focus on the your subject making the subject sharp and back ground blur this is normal a shallow DOF.It's sounds like your subject is a distance from the background and You could either have the subject stand close to the background you want in focus or change you aperture settings like John trav shows in the chart above,that way you can get the whole seen in focus.Hope that make sense and helps.
 
Last edited:
Hello JohnTrav,

I do understand that I have to study more about the photography features... but my concern is that, in automatic mode, is it right that the camera behave like this? Should it behave like a point and shoot in a portrait photo (a person in a background, without blurring the background)? Is it a problem with the camera?

Thanks

In automatic mode your camera will pick every setting and is pretty much guessing how you want the picture to turn out. So it all depends on how your camera thinks you want the picture to be. It is most likely doing what is stated above. Making sure ye subject is sharp and exposed correctly and that is making the background blurry.

I use to use full auto when I started out for the first couple weeks an don't get me wrong some pictures came out very nice. Once I started shooting manual though I never put my camera in full auto again. Aperture priority I use for sports so I can pick the ISO I want and the aperture I want and my camera will pick the shutter speed to make the proper exposure.

Play with your setting and see what you like. That chart I posted before is a nice reference.

Point and shoot cameras keep everything in focus because the aperture on them is always very small. So the DOF is always very large.

It's not a problem with your camera.
 
Hello JohnTrav,

I do understand that I have to study more about the photography features... but my concern is that, in automatic mode, is it right that the camera behave like this? Should it behave like a point and shoot in a portrait photo (a person in a background, without blurring the background)? Is it a problem with the camera?

Thanks

In automatic mode your camera will pick every setting and is pretty much guessing how you want the picture to turn out. So it all depends on how your camera thinks you want the picture to be. It is most likely doing what is stated above. Making sure ye subject is sharp and exposed correctly and that is making the background blurry.

I use to use full auto when I started out for the first couple weeks an don't get me wrong some pictures came out very nice. Once I started shooting manual though I never put my camera in full auto again. Aperture priority I use for sports so I can pick the ISO I want and the aperture I want and my camera will pick the shutter speed to make the proper exposure.

Play with your setting and see what you like. That chart I posted before is a nice reference.

Point and shoot cameras keep everything in focus because the aperture on them is always very small. So the DOF is always very large.

It's not a problem with your camera.


Thank you guys for the explanation...


I thought that, in the automatic mode, I would get the same behavior as a point and shoot camera...


I don't know if I made myself clear, but I realized that behavior when I tried to shoot (in automatic mode) a portrait with a person surrounded by a landscape (background), and I couldn't get any closer... in that way, the background (landscape) in the picture get blurred, but the person is really sharp...


Thank you
 
Last edited:
One of the primary differences between the T4i you bought and any point and shoot camera is the size of the sensor. The camera you're using has a larger sensor (APS-C sized) and therefore has a different rendering of depth of field. With a small sensor in a point and shoot, it renders almost everything in acceptably sharp focus, even at a somewhat wide aperture.

If you shoot at around 50mm at f/11-16 you'll have a pretty steep DoF depending on your subject to camera distance. HOWEVER, one of the major benefits of having a larger sensor is the ability to control your DoF and have better subject isolation.
 
The bottom line is that your new camera is working, not only as intended... but frankly most people HIGHLY desire a camera that can create a tack-sharp subject with a deliberately out-of-focus background. It helps draw a viewer's attention to the subject.

In full automatic mode, the camera has to size-up the exposure for the shot you'd like to take. It's allowed to use any ISO, shutter speed, or f-stop necessary to get an accurate exposure.

The camera doesn't know what you're trying to shoot or how you'd like it to look when you're in full auto mode. So it picks some middle-of-the-road safe settings.

If you WANT the background to be sharp, there are at least four different ways to do that. There is a caveat that I'll point out at the end that you DO want to know about.

1) Turn the dial to the scene mode which has the icon of the mountains with the cloud in the sky. That mode (landscape mode) tells the camera that you want the "widest possible" depth-of-field (the "depth of field" or "DoF" is the range of distances at which objects seem to be in acceptable focus.

2) Instead of using the green 'Auto' mode, switch the camera to 'Program' mode (that's the "P" on the mode dial). This mode stars out like auto mode, except you get to modify the settings. The neat bit is that when you modify the settings the camera automatically adjusts other settings to compensate. To adjust settings you do the following steps:

a) half-press the shutter button so that the camera 'meters' and focuses the shot.
b) Press the exposure lock button on the back of your camera. By default, that's the button with the asterisk (*) on it (but it is possible to remap the buttons.)
c) Rotate the main control dial (that's the dial just behind the shutter button on the top of the camera) and watch either through the viewfinder OR on the back LCD as you increase the f-stop. Dial it up to a higher value such as f/11 or even f/16 (the higher you take it, the broader the depth of field).

It's generally not necessary to go above f/16.
Be aware that the camera does not "remember" the settings between shots. Every time you re-meter the scene, the camera reverts back to what it wants to use (which is basically what it would have used in full-auto mode) but you can re-lock the exposure (press the "*") and turn the main control dial.

3) Use aperture priority mode. To use this, you set the mode dial to Av (Av = Aperture value). In this mode, YOU pick the aperture (or f-stop value) that you want the camera to use and the camera will automatically set everything else in order to get you that shot. This assumes you left the ISO set to 'Auto' and didn't pick a specific ISO. If you did pick a specific ISO then the camera wont change the ISO ... it will only change the shutter speed to create a balanced exposure.

4) Shoot in manual mode. I wont explain this here, but in manual mode, YOU set everything. You have full control over the exposure. The camera will offer you advice in that the light meter displayed when you look through the viewfinder has an arrow on a scale which ranges from -3 to +3. As you change settings, the arrow will slide left or right. When the arrow is centered, the camera thinks you picked a good exposure. Note that if the settings are more than 3 stops off what the camera believes is a good exposure then the arrow wont start moving until you get close.

You really should at least *learn* about shooting in manual, even if you choose not to use it. That's because the knowledge necessary to shoot in manual will give you a strong grounding in how exposure works and you'll be a better photographer for knowing that. As you approach a shot, you'll know what's realistic.

I mentioned above that there was a caveat that I'd mention. This is it:

When you make the aperture (the clear opening in your lens through which the light must pass in order to take a picture) smaller, you limit the amount of light that can be delivered to the sensor. This is much the same as filling a glass with water, but closing the tap on your sink so that the water flows at a trickle... it'll take a LOT longer to fill the glass when the water is hardly flowing.

That means if you dial the camera to a higher f-stop value (higher values actually represent SMALLER openings -- I know that seems counter-intuitive but the f-value represents the number of times that you can divide the diameter of the clear opening into the focal length of the lens) the camera needs to compensate for this reduced light somehow. It does this in two ways... it can increase the duration of time in which the shutter remains open, or it can increase the sensitivity of the camera sensor (increase the ISO setting). There are limits to how far it can adjust the ISO sensitivity... but there are practically no limits on how long it can increase the duration that the shutter remains open (there are, but the limits are so long that there may as well not be any limits).

But here's where I'm going with this: There's a point where the shutter speed is so slow that it's no longer possible to hand-hold the camera when you take the shot. No matter how still you attempt to stand, you'll move... just a tiny bit, but you will. And that movement (camera shake) will cause the image to be blurry... not because it was out of focus, but because the camera moved while the shutter was open. You could put the camera on a tripod so that it wont move... and if your subject is ALSO not moving, then you can take a photo as long as you want. If you are photographing a moving subject, you're now constrained by the fact the subject is moving so they will appear blurred with motion.

If you were shooting sports, for example, you need a fairly quick shutter speed to "freeze" the action... usually a shutter speed of 1/500th will freeze just about any action (all but the extreme motion). Most people who are actually trying to remain still would not appear blurred at 1/60th and possibly even 1/30th. Your camera lens also has image stabilization which helps you use a slower shutter speed that would normally be recommended for a lens that doesn't have image stabilization. Image stabilization is NOT a guarantee... it simply tips the odds greatly in your favor (you will still occasionally see a shot with blur due to camera motion EVEN when image stabilization was enabled. These will be "infrequent" but there's a difference between "infrequent" and "never". The occasionally blurry shot is not an indication of a defect. When you get into the weeds of how image stabilization actually works, you quickly learn there are limits to how far you can push it before it will no longer be able to "save you" from a blurred shot.
 
Hello guys,

Thank you very much for all those explanations, and thank you Tim Campbell, to explain me in baby-steps the whole process...

I am relief that my camera is not defective, heheh... 'cause I bought it in NYC, and I'm live in Brazil...

Well, what left me is study hard to get my new toy working properly heheh...

Problem solved... thank you very much...
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom