Now I'm super curious to what others would say. It looks better now on my home screen, but some parts still look to crispy (sorry can't describe it another way). That being said, it would look great printed large IMO. My wife just said she'd love to be there
edit: it looks perfect on my phone. I think it's me.
I'd probably crop the sides to the same view as in you first image, but IMO the extra space above & below mean it doesn't look quite so cramped as the first to me. Whilst nit-picking I think the reflections in the wider view are not as perfect as in your first one, making it difficult to decide on a favorite. I'd be happy to have taken either!
I think I've only been there between about march & the end of the summer holidays. - I've obviously got to visit more out of season, yet still get a bright day with little wind...