flower c&c which one is good?

[vd853]

which one do you like best? and why not the others?

 

[eccs19]

My choice would be the second one. A little more depth of field would have been nice on it. (if possible)

 

[reznap]

#2 I love - the shallow DOF works for me, the colors are great, no noise, etc..

#1 has distracting bright lines in it, really hurts the image. Looks like rope or something to tie the rosebush to something for support.

#3 is ok, but the white background is meh. Also the flower in focus blends into the one behind it which it out of focus - something I always notice on my own pics only when I open it up on the computer screen.

 

[RobNZ]

Im with reznap, 2 is really nice :thumbup:.

 

[sovietdoc]

second one looks nice

 

[Ron Evers]

#2 is the best but with cropping you might make #1 even better.

 

[Raizels]

I'm with the majority - #2 is my favorite. 3 is interesting too IMO.

 

[altitude604]

I'd crop #1 and #3, #2 is my favourite and I think it works quite well.

 

[dak1b]

#1 could use more light.