Flower Photo

[PhilGarber]

Hey all,

This is my best photograph. Please rate it on a scale of 1/10 (1 being worst). Also, should I do some retouching to remove the dust specs? Please tell me what I did right along with what I did wrong.

Thanks,

Phil,

 

[PhilGarber]

Bump.

 

[sertac]

I'm looking your Bubble
www.sps-bronze.com

 

[PhilGarber]

Thanks man! What'dya think? Neat site, right?

 

[PhilGarber]

anyone else?

 

[PhilGarber]

bump

 

[Bifurcator]

Following the tracker thread links.

Pretty cool man! I like it!

 

[Alpha]

I'd give it a 2.

Starting @10:
-5 points because it's mostly just another photo of a flower.
-3 points because the lack of fine detail isn't working for me.
-2 points for the stock composition.
+1 point because it's in focus.
+1 point because it's kind of interesting-looking.

 

[PhilGarber]

Thanks Bifurcator! I thought the Tracker Thread was a good idea! Thanks too Alpha! All feedback, good and constructive always helps!

 

[Do'Urden's Eyes]

the resolution is pretty low, so if its sharp i cant experience it properly.. Compositionally i give it a 4

 

[Rere]

Let's see.... I'll give it a 6. There are some blown highlights. But it has a modern, almost abstract, feel to it. I could see it enlarged a lot and hanging on a wall with modern decor.

 

[PhilGarber]

Let's see.... I'll give it a 6. There are some blown highlights. But it has a modern, almost abstract, feel to it. I could see it enlarged a lot and hanging on a wall with modern decor.

Thanks man! It is:mrgreen:! (on my wall)

 

[xxx_jpk_xxx]

I REALLY like this photo. I love how abstract it feels. I'd give it a solid 8. I mean, yeah, it is somewhat cliche, but it's different enough that it's still interesting. Plus, the B&W gives it a very dramatic feel.

 

[xxx_jpk_xxx]

I just checked out your Bubblesite and your photos are really good. You definitely have a good eye. I love your picture entitled "The Black White of the Fire" so much. I'd buy a print if I wasn't jobless.

 

[PhilGarber]

Thanks Jpk! It's really nice seeing someone that REALLY appreciates my work! Btw, I was looking at your site and I REALLY like your photos! I presume your using Photoshop?