Hallo, and welcome to ThePhotoForum, PhotoGal (who I am now constantly confusing with our long-time member photo_gal, who - on top of the almost identical screen names - also takes photos of this kind!), the first one is really nice with its old-time look! Only do I find it quite centred, so it could win even more if the rose were "shifted" (by cropping) more to the left. That would also take away some of the blown out area on the left. Might help.