I agree about the moon.
Also, maybe it's on a hill, but there is a very noticeable tilt in the landscape It's even more obvious in #2 because of the framing of the card.
i agree with plastic and wood, the moon is really big, maybe lowering it a bit would help, you know, how the moon always appears bigger the closer it is to the horizon... it's a great winter scene though...
Very nice. Hmm.. from reading The Crucible last year, I think I would liek the one with the big moon better if the overall picture was 'darker' in a sense, so I will choose the one with the smaller moon as being the better. But as I said.. an excellent Christmas themed picture!