too much saturation?

[oldnavy170]

Yeah, I personally like the reflection of the person too.

 

[a5i736]

am i the only person who likes when the reflection is out of there?

 

[meotter]

thank you for all of your responses i appreciate all of the input and effort fwiw, i prefer the reflection in there, but that was pretty cool how you removed it.

i'll keep working on it, perhaps i'll get unlazy and use PS on it to adjust the grass vs water seperately.

 

[nikonian2001]

am i the only person who likes when the reflection is out of there?

no I am right there with you it adds to the comp.

 

[a5i736]

no I am right there with you it adds to the comp.

thanks

 

[meotter]

no I am right there with you it adds to the comp.

what's comp? I thought it was composition perhaps? but if it is, then the shadow adding to the comp. would be a good thing and you'd want it included right?

 

[Digital Matt]

Let's keep this thread civil and on topic please. You can have your high school lunchroom fight via PM.

 

[darkmatter]

the reflection of the person for me is an additional element which makes the picture more intriguing.

 

[a5i736]

the reflection of the person for me is an additional element which makes the picture more intriguing.

I don't think the reflection makes it look more intriguing it just makes it look sloppy.

 

[JCleveland]

I think technically the first one is oversaturated. BUT I really like it! Kind of reminds me of Alice in Wonderland\Willy Wonka.. something of that nature.

 

[elsaspet]

I like the more saturated but then again, I'm a color freak.