Hey, Anty has said all I meant to say. I could copy her words and "sell" them as mine, but I am not like that.
Ah. One thought I had when I looked at the first here: I think the inclusion of the bit of brightness from the window takes away from it. Our eyes are invariably drawn to the brightest part of what we see, so they are drawn away from the pies and their reflection in the ... whatever it is, and towards the window sill, the cropped jug and the light outside. Test a different crop, if you want to, only a little in from above as far as you don't begin to crop into the reflection of the pies, and then the adequate bit off the left and see what the pic looks like after that. Maybe?