which crop is best?

kidkrazy · Feb 28, 2006

all three photos are different crops of the original, which one do you like best? This is a photo of Mt. McKinley.

JTHphoto · Feb 28, 2006

i think i prefer the third one the best, maybe try another crop from the top right, cropping out some of the excess sky from the top and just enough from the right to eliminate the guard/hand railing... nice shot :thumbup:

nvr2low · Feb 28, 2006

i think i prefer number 2, just think it looks good

tgates · Feb 28, 2006

I like #1

Calliope · Feb 28, 2006

#1 for me! Nice shot btw.

Peanuts · Feb 28, 2006

#1 also here

crawdaddio · Feb 28, 2006

Alexandra · Feb 28, 2006

#1

cause in the other two, the tips of the trees at the bottom are really distracting

macawlvr · Feb 28, 2006

I like #1 I see it as a pano..nice photo either way you crop it.

Trish

Insomniac · Feb 28, 2006

Another for number 1.

ClarkKent · Feb 28, 2006

#1 also. Nice capture.

kidkrazy · Mar 1, 2006

Thank you all. I also prefer #1. I think it brings the focus on the mountain and that's the point of the photo. It almost does the mountain justice.

Christie Photo · Mar 3, 2006

The horizon line falls near the center in all. Have you tried cropping the sky so as to move the horizon line higher in the composition? I tried it on #2 by scrolling... might be something you like.

Pete