I sometimes like the playful effects you can do to your photos in PS, and this is a very good example of a picture where it worked! It is "playing" with the photo for me in most cases, though. But if the outcome pleases the eye as much as these bottles in the bottle bank do, then ok.
Only am I not too sure about the left upper corners in both photos.
It would have been interesting to see a thus manipulated photo with ONLY bottles, no edge of the bin.