Here's a photo of some falls we came across on a kayak trip in Ontario. Light was fading, so the shutter speed was a little slower than I would have liked, causing the water to look soft.
Karissa, could it be that bit of sky in the upper right hand corner that is bothering you?
For I feel I'd like this photo even more if it were gone.
A slightly different position might have helped.
What could help now (I tested this by scrolling the upper part out of my screen) is cropping all the upper part, so we'd only see the rocks and the water and the place where it "lands".
Plus I find the water looks near to perfect in this one: you see it's movement - the "foggy water"-waterfall-photos look so rushed, so fast to me. I like this better.
A tad more contrast could help, I think.