The vignetting is not good. It looks really unnatural and amateurish. Sorry.
3. Could stand to gain a little warmth.
4. I have no idea what you did with processing here, but it doesn't work at all. Their faces are blown, and the vignetting against the blown out...sepia tone? No bueno
6. You shot against the sun and then tried to pull them back using a lot of contrast... and it shows. Your blacks are like... UBER black. Those black have gone down into the depths of hell never to see the light of "just normal black" again.
If you don't want a washed out look, don't shoot your subjects against the sun.
11. If you absolutely must do the heart thing... this is the best one. Don't give your subjects... clients... whatever, 3 different versions of the same shot. Don't process 3 different versions of the same shot. Just pick the best one and go with it.
13. Out of all of these... I'd actually say that I like this one. HOWEVER... that keychain on his pants... has GOT to go. The way his shirt is pulling back after tucking his hands in... I would have had him pull it back forward or done it myself.
Her expression looks worried or annoyed and his looks annoyed as well.
14. I think this is the cutest one of them, but that vignetting has GOTS TA GO.
15. She looks like she's hugging this dude, but thinking about that summer long ago with Juan... and wonders if it COULD have worked out had called her excitedly on the phone to say, "Joanna! I'm coming home early! I was wrong to go away for so long! I LOVE YOU! MARRY ME!!!!"
I would have had her maybe lookingly slightly down... smiling... Even looking the way she is looking now with a happier expression would have been alright.
Her face is blown out though.
I won't even mention the vignetting this time.
...vignetting.
......vignetting.
.........be gone vignetting.
