What's new

another landscape - mono vs color

barleymalt

TPF Noob!
Joined
Jul 2, 2010
Messages
142
Reaction score
2
Can others edit my Photos
Photos OK to edit
another one from the winter mist series. whats your preference?

5435446193_f40ca4860e_b.jpg


5436076480_b21c887ec8_b.jpg
 
Last edited:
Wow...they're both beautiful, and the different renderings capture different moods. I guess the 'correct' one is the version that best expresses your feeling when you visualized the scene.
 
Well said! I have to agree.
 
Colour version...makes the trees stand out more.
 
BW for me. The color version looks too processed to me. The sky (colors) looks too unnatural to me.
 
My personal preference is the B&W version, but do have to say that both are gorgeous. Nicely done!
 
I prefer the color version, the clouds have more punch.
 
Thanks for your opinions guys! Think I've settled with the B&W myself.
 
Not a fan of the colours in the sky; so that makes me lean towards the B&W. It feels as though it could use a little more contrast though.

Interested to know how you did your B&W conversion... lightening the water and darkening the trees a little could make they really stand out as the focal point of the image.

Overall great capture.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top Bottom