Well, you are in the States, so things are different, and it is no use I ask if you got release, you will say "public place" and all that ... I would never show photos of children (candids) without signed release by their parents (other than the one little boy who I photographed in a park in clearest view of his parents who never said anything against it, so I took that as a silent agreement). For me, this is a touchy subject.
That said, I must say: the last is best.
In many, the shadowed areas in which they were compete with the sun-lit background and some fill-flash would possibly have helped.
The scene captured in 4 is nice and tells a story. I like that!
Thank you for the critique. :thumbup:
I have another one that I really like, that tells more of a story than #4-- but now I'm not sure if I should post it because of the parent consent issue.
I would think that it would be fine since I didn't classify where I saw these children or what their names were, but I understand your point completely. Although, on numbers 1, 2, 5, 6, and 7, I fell into much the same situation as you with the park shot. The parents were near by, practically on the structures with the children, or even watching me in those shots, and didn't say anything about me photographing their children. Then again, they most likely didn't know that I would be posting those said shots on the internet... although, on the other hand, if they had any concerns at all I would expect them to speak up.
But as for #'s 3 and 4, there was just an adult 'yard duty' nearby watching me. She didn't express any concerns, but then again, I don't know if she was a parent and even thought about having concerns. Just like, I never thought about this matter until you brought it up-- which makes sense, since you're a parent and I'm sure you'd absolutely need to give your consent before letting a random stranger photograph your child.
So, thank you for bringing this up, since I was totally unaware to it.
Now, from a moderator's point of view, do you think I should delete #'s 3 and 4?